Ideas / From Intelligence to Agency
Moral Crumple Zones: Cautionary Tales in Human-Robot Interaction
Madeleine Clare Elish
Madeleine Clare Elish shows how humans with little control can absorb the blame when automated systems fail.
An organization can give control to an automated system while leaving a nominal human nearby. When the system fails, responsibility may collapse onto that person, who had little power to prevent the failure.
Elish calls this the moral crumple zone: the human operator absorbs the moral and legal impact, preserving the integrity of the larger system. The machine keeps its job.